Document Type : Systematic Review
Authors
1 PhD Student of Reproductive Health, Student Research Committee, School of Nursing and Midwifery, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran
2 PhD Student, Proteomics Research Center, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran
3 MSc, Research Center for Prevention of Psychosocial Impairment, Ilam University of Medical Sciences, Ilam, Iran
4 Assistant Professor, Midwifery and Reproductive Health Research Center, Department of Midwifery and Reproductive Health, School of Nursing and Midwifery, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran
Abstract
Keywords
Main Subjects
Introduction
Menopause is the time in a woman's life when fertility period ceases. This period is considered a critical transition period in a woman’s reproductive life. Age of menopause is a determinant of health status and risk of future diseases in women (1). Natural menopause is defined as the permanent absence of menstrual periods for 12 months without any pathological causes as a result of the absence of ovarian follicular activity (2) .
Biochemical and hormonal changes in this period lead to physical and psychological symptoms and changes in the quality of life in this population (3). Menopause age varies among different female populations (4). A woman’s menopause age is affected by a number of factors, including the age at which the woman’s mother and sister experience menopause (5), gravidity, body mass index (BMI), smoking (3), physical activity, and place of residence (6). A woman’s age at natural menopause is a predictor of postmenopausal diseases and mortality (7).
Age of menopause is an important health indicator. In this regard, each year of increase in menopause age will reduce the total mortality rate by 2%, as well as the mortality due to acute cardiac ischemia (8). Moreover, early menopause will enhance the risk of cardiovascular diseases, osteoporosis, and mental disorders (9). On the other hand, late menopause is associated with a higher risk of breast cancer (10). Iranian population is making transition from a young age structure to an old age one as a consequence of medical advances, higher life expectancies, and lower birth rates.
According to the World Health Organization (WHO), the Iranian population aged 60+ will increase to 33% over the coming 35 years (i.e., by 2050) (11). Accordingly, there would be a rise in the number of postmenopausal women in Iran over the coming years. The evaluation of menopause age plays a significant role in the management of postmenopausal complications through national health policies. With this background in mind, the present study was conducted to evaluate the average age of menopause among Iranian women through a meta-analysis.
Methods
The present systematic review and meta-analysis was conducted to identify the average age of menopause among Iranian women in August 2017. This study was performed based on preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses checklist. For the purpose of the study, the articles related to the subject of interest were searched in several Persian databases, including Iran Medex, SID, and Magiran, as well as a number of international databases, including Scopus, PubMed, and Web of Knowledge. The search process was performed using the following keywords: “Menopause” OR “Menopause age” OR “Age at menopause” OR “Menopause age and Iran”.
Only cross-sectional studies were included in the study. The search process resulted in the identification of 605 articles, 574 cases of which were removed after scanning their titles and abstracts due to irrelevancy, absence of a full-text version, and duplication. In the final stage, 28 articles were included in the review process after assessment for eligibility (Figure 1). The cross-sectional studies that had considered the mean age of healthy postmenopausal women at natural menopause or applied prospective methods were included in the study.
The recorded data included the mean and standard deviation of age at menopause, author’s name, year of publication, sample size, and demographic characteristics of the study participants. For the purpose of searching for the articles, first, a list of titles and a summary of all articles available at the databases were searched by two independent researchers. After the removal of the duplicate or irrelevant articles, the full-text versions of the articles were investigated by the two researchers. In case of disagreement between the two researchers, a third person re-examined the article to achieve a consensus.
A critical appraisal tool was used to assess the quality of the included cross-sectional studies. This valid tool facilitated the assessment of the introduction, methods, results, and discussion, and 2 other questions. This tool entailed 20 questions, each of which was answered through selecting “Yes”, “No”, or “Don’t Know”. This valid tool is applied for review studies (12). In this scale, the total score ranges between 0 and 20; in this regard, the studies with a score of 16 or more were included in the review process.
Heterogeneity among study was checked using Q test with α2 index. Begg’s and Egger tests were also adopted to identify the publication bias. Random effect model and Stata statistical software
Figure 1. Flowchart presenting the process of article selection
(version 14) were used for data analysis regarding the study heterogeneity.
Results
The number of the participants of the reviewed studies corresponded to a total of 40,042 women. In order to estimate age of menopause in Iran, 28 articles published during 1998-2017 were analyzed (Table 1). The results of the Chi-square test indicated that heterogeneity was significant for all subgroups; furthermore, I2 index showed that heterogeneity for all subgroups was above 90%.
The mean age of menopause in 28 studies was evaluated as 48.57 years (CI: 47.96-49.18, I2=99.9, Pheterogeneity=0.000; χ2=44491.96, P=0.001; Figure 3). The majority of the reviewed articles investigated the center of Iran (10), furthermore, 5 studies were related to the north, east (6), west (2), and south (3), and 2 cases had been conducted at a national level. In a meta-analysis study conducted in 2011, the average age of menopause was reported as 48.14 years; however, as our results demonstrated, this age has reached to 48.57 by 2017.
With regard to subgroup analysis, the average ages of menopause were evaluated as 47.21 (CI: 46.94-47.48, I2=94.7, Pheterogeneity=0.000) and 48.438 (CI: 47.76-49.10, I2=97.4, Pheterogeneity=0.000) years in eight studies among smoking and non-smoking women, respectively. The BMI was calculated in three groups of normal, overweight, and obese women. Based on 9, 7, and 6 studies, the average ages
Table 1. Information of the included studies
General characteristics of study participants |
Population |
Age (year) |
Sample size |
Location |
Author (year)/ references |
1.4% smoker/ 37.1% obese/ 37.1% overweight 63.6% living in urban areas, 36.4% living in rural areas |
50-60 |
51.20±5.31 |
4898 |
11 regions |
Parsaeian M. (2017) (23) |
11.49% obese, mean of menarche age: 13.15 years |
<75 |
48.66 ± 3.79 |
960 |
Isfahan |
Golshiri P. (2016) (24) |
44.1% overweight, 22.7% obese |
31-59 |
48.56±3.35 |
289 |
Kerman |
Foroud A. (2016) (25) |
mean menarche age: 13.6±1.3 years |
43-65 |
49.60±4.02 |
400 |
Hamadan |
Shobeiri F. (2014) (26) |
21.6% smoker, 40.2% overweight, 37.1% obese |
35-65 |
52[51.9-52.5] |
2498 |
Mashhad |
Esmaili H. (2013) (27) |
0.5% smoker, 40.8% overweight, 39.2% obese |
30-60 |
47.60± 4.45 |
804 |
Golestan |
Abdollahi A. (2013) (28) |
mean BMI: 24.19±3.6 kg/m2 |
29-73 |
46.57±4.95 |
403 |
Tehran |
Jafaree F. (2011) (29) |
mean age at menarche: 13.29±0.71 years |
>46 |
50.02±0.21 |
300 |
Mazandaran |
Faghani Aghoozi M. (2011) (30) |
34.4% obese, 1% smoker |
45-63 |
47.70± 4.90 |
1397 |
Mazandaran |
Agajani Delavar M (2011) (31) |
1% smoker, mean BMI: 29.2±5.0 kg/m2, mean age at menarche: 13.3±1.6 years |
45-63 |
46.60±5.60 |
1620 |
Mazandaran |
Delavar M. A. (2011) (32) |
6.7% smoker, 33.4% overweight, 31.8% obese |
35-65 |
49.60±4.50 |
1114 |
Tehran |
Farahmand M. (2010) (33) |
8.7% smoker |
45-55 |
47.13±3.90 |
1500 |
Tehran |
Nahidi F. (2010) (34) |
- |
>30 |
52.40±5.02 |
3404 |
Semnan |
Sadat Hashemi M. (2009) (35) |
- |
------- |
49.49±3.30 |
140 |
Khuzestan |
Ziaee S. (2009) (36) |
- |
36-60 |
49.90±3.62 |
140 |
Kashan |
Kafaee M. (2008) (37) |
32% overweight, 26% obese |
40-70 |
47.39±5.09 |
346 |
Yazd |
Fallahzadeh H. (2007) (38) |
5.4% smoker |
>35 |
47.71 |
2462 |
Tehran |
Ashrafi M. (2007) (39) |
7% smoker, 10% obese and overweight |
<60 |
47.30±6.30 |
500 |
Sistan and Bluchestan |
Ansari H. (2007) (40) |
50.4% living in urban areas, 49.6% living in rural areas 48% overweight, 7.6% obese |
-------- |
48.20±2.34 |
458 |
Arak |
Rafee M. (2006) (41) |
- |
40-60 |
47.97±4.17 |
1612 |
Khuzestan |
Nuhjah S. (2005) (42) |
5% smoker, 38.4% overweight, 29.5% obese |
------ |
48.30± 5.30 |
948 |
Shiraz |
Ayatollahi H. (2005) (43) |
- |
30-65 |
50.40±4.30 |
8194 |
- |
Mohammad K. (2004) (44) |
26.8% overweight, 31% obese |
46-50 |
47.63±4.94 |
400 |
East Azarbayjan |
Shahnazarli G. (2004) (45) |
8.5% smoker, mean age at menarche: 13.5±1.61 years |
39-87 |
48.51±4.45 |
441 |
Tehran |
Jahanfar S. (2002) (46) |
54% living in urban areas, 46% living in rural areas |
40-55 |
47.93±4.37 |
3036 |
Mazandaran |
Abdollahi F. (2002) (47) |
30.5% overweight, 12.1% obese |
>40 |
47.19±5.31
|
807 |
South Khorasan |
Mortazavi Moghadam G. (2000) (48) |
mean BMI: 24.65±3.77 kg/m2, 30.2% living in urban areas, 69.8% living in rural areas |
40-55 |
46.34±3.69 |
398 |
Razavi Khorasan |
Askari F. (2000) (49) |
3.3% smoker |
40-60 |
48.40±4.70 |
573 |
Kerman |
Kamyabi Z. (1998) (50) |
Figure 2. Funnel plot for checking publication bias
Figure 3. Evaluation of the average age of menopause according to random effects model, the author’s name, and year of study (each line segment is indicating a confidence interval of 95%. The diamond sign shows the evaluation of a combination of total average ages of menopause and confidence interval in each subgroup.)
of menopause in the normal, overweight, and obese groups were obtained as 47.53 (CI: 47.17-47.88, I2=91.3, Pheterogeneity=0.000), 47.80 (CI: 47.49-48.11, I2=83.4, Pheterogeneity=0.000), and 47.83 (CI: 47.34-48.32, I2=93.3, Pheterogeneity=0.000) years, respectively.
The results of Begg’s funnel plot and Egger test (P=0.221) demonstrated that publication bias was not significant. Figure 2 illustrates the funnel plot for checking the publication bias. The mean ages of menopause during the time courses of 1998-2004, 2005-2009, 2010-2014, and 2014-2017 were estimated as 48 (46.68-49.33), 48.74 (47.44-50.04), 48.54 (47.40-49.68), and 49.48 (47.52-51.43) years, respectively.
Based on the geographical regions, the maximum mean menopause age was 50.8 years in two national studies, while the minimum mean age was 47.97 years related to the north region. In addition, the mean ages for the studies conducted at a national level and in the north, east, west, south, and center of Iran were 50.8 (50.01-51-580), 47.97 (46-47-49.48), 48.23 (46.35-50.12), 48.62 (46.69-50.55), 48.54 (47.83-49.26), and 48.61 (47.47-49.75) years, respectively.
To evaluate heterogeneity, a meta-regression was run between the years of publication and sample size of studies and menopause age. The results revealed that the sample size of studies and menopause age were significant (P=0.01). However, the years of publication was not significant (P=0.06).
Discussion
Based on the analysis of 28 studies, the average age of menopause in Iran was estimated as 48.57 (CI: 47.96-49.18) years. In a systematic review and meta-analysis study performed in 2014, the average age of menopause in six countries was obtained as 48.3 (CI: 48.78-49.2) years (13). It seems that menopause-related changes may arise from different biological factors (e.g., genetic and nutritional factors or history of reproduction) across different geographical locations. These variations can be also affected by such factors as lifestyle, occupation, smoking, place of residence, and socioeconomic status (3, 14).
In our study, the average ages of menopause in eight studies were estimated as 47.21 (CI: 46.94-47.48) and 48.43 (CI: 47.76-49.10) years in smoking and non-smoking women, respectively. Younger age of menopause will increase several types of physical and psychological complications. Early menopause is associated with some 2% of annual mortality and increased risk of cardiovascular disease, diabetes, and osteoporosis (15).
Based on the evidence, long-term smoking will reduce the age of menopause. In the same vein, the duration and severity of smoking (i.e., the number of cigarettes used per day) affect the menopause age (16). According to a number of studies, the detrimental effect of cigarette on the number of children and female reproductive system paves the way for the incidence of early menopause (17).
There are different assumptions on the relationship of the biological effects of smoking with early menopause. In this regard, it has been stated that the smoking women have a more significant drop in estradiol levels in the middle of their menstrual cycle and luteal phase as compared to the non-smoking ones. Experimental models suggest that nicotine causes follicle loss in ovaries and blocks aromatase enzyme that is responsible for the conversion of androgen to estrogen (18).
In our study, the average age of menopause in the overweight group (mean: 47.80; CI: 47.49-48.11) was higher than that of the group with a normal BMI (mean: 47.53; CI: 47.17-47.88). Accordingly, the obese group had the highest average age of menopause (mean: 47.83; CI: 47.34-48.32).
In a study carried out by Tao et al. (2015), the hazard ratios of early menopause in overweight and obese women were reported as 0.92 and 0.88, respectively, which were higher than the ratio obtained for underweight women (19). Adipose tissues in obese people increase the production of estrogen as a result of the conversion of androgen to estrogen in the peripheral adipose tissue, thereby leading to late menopause (20).
It seems that the high prevalence of obesity in Iran can result in late menopause in the near future. Although menopause age is currently within a normal range with an increasing slope, it may exceed the normal range if this trend continues. According to the literature, although late menopause can reduce the hazard ratio (0.98) of cardiovascular diseases per year, it increases the risk of gynecological cancers (8).
The results of our study showed that in the time course of 1998-2009, the average menopause age increased from 48 to 48.74 years. However, during 2010-2014, it decreased to 48.54 years, and then underwent an increase to 49.48 years from 2014 to 2017. Based on the geographical region, the women in the north region had the lowest mean age (47.97 years). Generally, it seems that many factors, such as diet, race, and reproductive issues, can affect this issue.
The results of the present study suggested that in Iran, the average age at menopause is increasing with a gentle slope per year. Although this relationship is not statistically significant, it is very critical regarding the great impact of menopause on women’s health. In line with our study, in a European study, it was reported that menopause age differs across Europe and shifts towards an older age.
The strength of our study is the analysis of menopause age in terms of different time courses and geographical regions of Iran, which showed that the age of menopause varies across different times and regions. Additionally, the results of this study are very powerful given its cohort design. One of the limitations of this study is the use of medical records for data collection. Furthermore, none of the included studies reported the effect of chemical exposure on menopause age; therefore, this issue remained unaddressed, which is another limitation of this research.
Furthermore, all included studies were cross-sectional. The accuracy of reporting menopause age can be different in each study, which may have affected our results. In addition, many confounding factors, such as race, reproductive factors, and lifestyle, should be adjusted when estimating the menopause age. The physical well-being and life satisfaction among menopausal women should be also taken into account (21). With regard to the transition of Iranian life style from traditional to modern (22), the health threatening factors during menopausal period should be given more attention.
Implications for Practice
As the results of the current study indicated, the average age of menopause is still within a normal range in Iran despite its rise with a normal slope. It seems that the change in women’s lifestyle have affected the menopause age. Some remediable factors that confound menopause age among Iranian women need special attention to promote women’s health. Consequently, health providers should plan for monitoring the health of premenopausal and menopausal women.
Acknowledgments
This study is related to the project NO:1396/46456 From Student Research Committee, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran. We also appreciate the “Student Research Committee” and “Research & Technology Chancellor” in Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences for their financial support of this study.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors declare no conflicts of interest.